Using our own Dialects
In class we are learning various things that are very interesting and sometimes extremely shocking. Specifically this week, we learned about he importance of dialects through two different assigned reading and class discussions. One of the reading SRTOL had really good points on how as English students we should be allowed to not only communicate in English but also in our native dialects. Not only that the reading also talked about something that really caught my attention was that we associate speaking English correctly with an image of a wealthy white person and most of the times a wealthy white male. I had never though or even heard the saying “Writing right is Writing White” until it was said in our class during our discussion.
It’s honestly
really crazy to see how we can judge a person who isn’t white based on how they
speak English and straight up say they aren’t speaking English correctly when
most of the time we understand them! Reading this declaration I was so pro
using our dialect in English to allow everyone to comfortable express them selves
and let people hear their voice until I read the counter argument.
After
reading the counter argument I realized that maybe we shouldn’t write the way
we want or in our personal discourse or dialect. It felt so weird to ready such
informal writing like that. It might be because I’m so internally oppressed
that I can’t detach from my oppressed nature. I will admit that I understood
the writing in the second reading and I identify with most of it because the
language use can be linked to some of my personal discourses.
But that isn’t the
only reason why I think that maybe we shouldn’t be using our own dialects and
discourse language be cause not everyone can actually know every language/discourse/dialect
that exists. Its simply impossible. Communicating in different dialects can
create barriers in communication when in reality we should try to build communication
and understanding between individuals but them it comes to accepting all parts
of an individual, which includes their dialects, or discourse language.
Over all it is
very complicated to actually take a side in this debate. I love writing in my
own voice but then again I feel like even in this blog post I am not exactly writing
in my voice even though it feel like I am. I feel like I have many voices .For example,
I have a super academic one that I use in class or at an interview. A semi academic
voice, which I am using right now, and my voice I use with my friends. So I
understand how dialects and discourse specific language plays a role in my life
but I can also see what problems it can cause for people outside my discourse.
Great post! I had the same problem while reading the 3rd reading. Yes, I understood what the author was saying, but since It wasn't what I'm use to I thought it was weird. It's not even that it's weird, it is something different and abnormal so we automatically judge it. I know that was my issue.
ReplyDeleteI thought your blog was very relatable. I felt weird to even speak in my own language in class, so I know I don't really feel comfortable writing in my own language in English class it isn't natural for me once I step in the classroom.
ReplyDeleteLoved your blog! I totally relate to you! I too feel like I have to have different, you can say faces or personalities on how I act around different people I encounter with too.
ReplyDelete